Why does Romeo and Juliet still earn its place in the English classroom, even when it’s so often misunderstood? This reflective teaching post explores why Shakespeare’s most over-romanticised play continues to work with students, examining impulsiveness, authority, and avoidable loss rather than idealised love. By reframing the play away from romance and towards consequence, Romeo and Juliet becomes far more relevant — and far more teachable. Drawing on classroom experience, this post explores how and why to teach Romeo and Juliet, from contextualising it within Shakespeare’s wider work to using discussion, creative writing, and debate to deepen understanding. It also shares classroom-tested strategies and resources designed to support meaningful engagement with the play across secondary English.