100 Christmas Persuasive Writing Topics & Debate Ideas for Students

Christmas is full of traditions, celebrations and strong opinions. Should schools ban homework over the festive holidays? Is Christmas becoming too commercialised? Should real Christmas trees be replaced with artificial ones? And is it ever acceptable to regift an unwanted present?

From lighthearted arguments about festive food and Christmas films to thought-provoking discussions about consumerism, environmental responsibility and social expectations, the holiday season offers endless opportunities for persuasive writing and classroom debate.

This collection of 100 Christmas persuasive writing topics and debate ideas is designed to help students develop their opinions, construct convincing arguments and explore different perspectives. Whether you're teaching persuasive essays, argumentative writing, speech writing or debating skills, these festive questions provide engaging starting points for meaningful discussion and independent writing.

Organised into 10 themed categories, the topics cover everything from Christmas traditions and school celebrations to winter weather, ethical dilemmas and unusual festive controversies. You'll find accessible questions for younger learners alongside more challenging issues for middle school and high school students, making it easy to select activities appropriate for different ages and abilities.

Each prompt encourages students to take a position, consider opposing viewpoints and support their arguments with logical reasoning, persuasive language and relevant examples. Teachers can use the questions for individual writing assignments, persuasive speeches, paired discussions, structured classroom debates or quick seasonal bell-ringer activities.

And because persuasive writing should be about more than simply stating an opinion, you'll also find practical teaching ideas, persuasive writing techniques and sentence starters to help students transform their initial thoughts into well-developed arguments.

Looking for more writing inspiration? Explore our Creative Writing Archive for a wide range of writing prompts, story starters and imaginative activities, including seasonal creative writing prompts for Christmas, winter and beyond.

So, whether your students believe Christmas should last all year or think festive celebrations have become far too extravagant, there's one thing everyone can agree on: Christmas provides plenty to argue about!

Explore the 100 Christmas Writing Topics

1. Christmas at School 2. Christmas Traditions 3. Gifts & Shopping 4. Christmas Food 5. Movies & Music 6. Kindness & Ethics 7. Christmas & the Environment 8. Winter & Snow Days 9. Funny Christmas Debates 10. Challenging Debates

Persuasive Writing Tips & Classroom Activities

What Is Persuasive Writing?

Persuasive writing is a form of writing designed to convince readers to agree with a particular opinion, argument or point of view. Rather than simply describing a subject or sharing personal preferences, persuasive writers use logical reasoning, relevant evidence and carefully chosen language to influence how their audience thinks or feels.

For example, imagine you're asked: Should schools ban homework over the Christmas holidays?

A simple opinion might be: "Schools should ban Christmas homework because students deserve a break."

A stronger persuasive argument would explain why students need time away from academic responsibilities, explore the benefits of rest and family time, and address the opposing argument that homework helps maintain learning.

Effective persuasive writing often includes several important techniques:

• Rhetorical questions encourage readers to consider a particular viewpoint.

• Emotive language appeals to the audience's feelings and values.

• Facts and evidence make arguments more credible and convincing.

• Direct address engages readers by speaking to them personally.

• Counterarguments acknowledge opposing opinions before explaining why another position may be stronger.

Persuasive writing can take many forms, including essays, speeches, letters, advertisements and opinion articles. It also shares important skills with classroom debating, where students must defend their positions, respond to opposing arguments and communicate their ideas clearly.

The Christmas persuasive writing topics below provide opportunities to practise these skills through familiar festive traditions, entertaining controversies and more challenging ethical questions. Each topic can be adapted into a persuasive essay, argumentative speech, classroom debate or discussion activity, making them suitable for a wide range of ages and abilities.

1. Christmas at School: Rules, Homework & Celebrations

Should Christmas be a time for learning, celebrating or taking a complete break from school? From festive homework assignments and classroom decorations to Christmas performances and end-of-term activities, schools face plenty of decisions that students might not agree with.

These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics encourage students to question school traditions, consider different perspectives and develop convincing arguments about how schools should celebrate the festive season. Each question can be used as a persuasive essay topic, speech prompt or classroom debate.

1. Should Schools Ban Homework Over the Christmas Holidays?

Christmas holidays are supposed to offer students an opportunity to rest, spend time with family and enjoy activities outside the classroom. However, some teachers believe that assigning homework helps students retain knowledge, develop independence and prepare for the new term.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive letter to your headteacher arguing whether Christmas homework should be banned entirely. Consider whether the benefits of uninterrupted relaxation outweigh the potential consequences of taking an extended break from academic work.

2. Should Schools Be Allowed to Cancel Lessons for Christmas Activities?

During the final weeks of term, some schools replace ordinary lessons with Christmas films, craft activities, parties and festive competitions. While students often welcome these celebrations, others argue that valuable teaching time is being wasted.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a persuasive speech arguing whether schools should dedicate an entire day to Christmas activities. Consider the importance of academic progress, student wellbeing and creating positive school memories.

3. Should Christmas Jumper Day Be Compulsory?

Christmas Jumper Day is a popular school tradition, often organised to raise money for charity. However, not every student owns a festive jumper, and some families may struggle with the additional expense. Others simply dislike being expected to participate in themed clothing days.

Persuasive writing challenge: Argue whether schools should make Christmas Jumper Day compulsory, optional or replace it with a more inclusive fundraising activity. Consider affordability, charitable giving and the importance of allowing students to make their own choices.

4. Should Schools Stop Giving Students Christmas Tests and Assessments?

The weeks leading up to Christmas can be stressful for students preparing for examinations, completing assignments and meeting deadlines. Some believe schools should avoid scheduling assessments during December, allowing students to enjoy the festive season without additional pressure. Others argue that delaying assessments disrupts learning and creates more stress in January.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an opinion article for your school newspaper arguing whether schools should introduce a Christmas assessment-free period. Use logical reasoning and acknowledge at least one opposing viewpoint.

5. Should Every School Have a Christmas Tree?

Decorating a Christmas tree can create a welcoming atmosphere and encourage a sense of community. However, schools serve students from a wide range of religious, cultural and personal backgrounds, and not everyone celebrates Christmas. Some argue that schools should embrace traditional decorations, while others favour displays that recognise different winter celebrations.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive letter to your school governors arguing whether Christmas trees should be displayed in every school. Consider cultural inclusion, school traditions and how shared spaces can reflect a diverse community.

6. Should Students Be Allowed to Choose Their Own Christmas Activities?

Teachers often organise festive activities based on what they believe students will enjoy, but not everyone wants to participate in Christmas crafts, singing competitions or classroom parties. Some students would prefer reading, creative writing, games or simply spending time with friends.

Persuasive writing challenge: Argue whether students should have the final say in planning end-of-term Christmas activities. Consider student independence, fairness, classroom organisation and whether majority decisions always produce the best outcomes.

7. Should Schools Replace Christmas Performances with More Modern Celebrations?

Traditional Christmas concerts, nativity plays and carol services remain popular in many schools. However, rehearsals can take weeks, some students experience performance anxiety, and others feel uncomfortable participating in religious or musical activities.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a speech for a school council meeting arguing whether traditional Christmas performances should continue or be replaced with alternative celebrations. Consider the value of tradition, creativity, inclusivity and student confidence.

8. Should Schools Allow Christmas Music During Lessons?

Some students claim that Christmas music creates a cheerful classroom atmosphere, reduces stress and makes routine activities more enjoyable. Others find festive songs repetitive, distracting or irritating, particularly when the same music is played throughout December.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive argument supporting or opposing the use of Christmas music during lessons. Consider whether background music improves concentration, how personal preferences differ and whether teachers should control the classroom environment.

9. Should Schools Organise Secret Santa Gift Exchanges?

Secret Santa exchanges can encourage generosity, friendship and festive excitement. However, they may also create financial pressure, lead to disappointing gifts or leave students feeling excluded. Even when spending limits are introduced, not every family can comfortably afford additional Christmas presents.

Persuasive writing challenge: Argue whether schools should organise Secret Santa activities or replace them with celebrations that do not involve spending money. Consider fairness, inclusion, social pressure and the meaning of generosity.

10. Should Schools Finish Earlier for the Christmas Holidays?

As Christmas approaches, students and teachers often become increasingly tired, and some argue that the final days of term offer limited educational value. Finishing school earlier could provide families with more time to prepare for the holidays, but it might also create childcare difficulties and reduce valuable learning opportunities.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal letter to your local education authority arguing whether schools should close several days earlier for Christmas. Support your position with clear reasoning, address the possible disadvantages and propose a practical solution.

2. Christmas Traditions: Keep Them or Change Them?

From decorating Christmas trees and exchanging presents to hanging stockings and celebrating on Christmas Eve, festive traditions play an important role in how families and communities experience the holiday season. But just because something has been done for generations, does that mean it should continue?

These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics invite students to question familiar customs, explore changing attitudes and consider whether traditions should be preserved, adapted or abandoned altogether. Each question offers opportunities to develop balanced arguments, challenge assumptions and defend a personal viewpoint.

11. Should Christmas Traditions Be Preserved Even When They Become Outdated?

Many Christmas traditions have been passed down through generations, connecting families to their history and creating a sense of belonging. However, changing lifestyles, cultural expectations and family circumstances mean that some customs may no longer feel relevant or enjoyable. Should traditions be protected simply because they have existed for a long time?

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive essay arguing whether preserving Christmas traditions is more important than adapting celebrations to suit modern life. Consider cultural heritage, personal freedom and whether traditions lose their meaning when people feel obliged to follow them.

12. Should Christmas Decorations Be Banned Until December?

Every year, Christmas decorations seem to appear earlier in shops, homes and public spaces. Some people enjoy extending the festive atmosphere throughout November, while others believe that celebrating too early makes Christmas feel less special. But should anyone have the right to decide when the Christmas season officially begins?

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive speech arguing whether shops and public buildings should be prohibited from displaying Christmas decorations before 1 December. Consider commercial interests, personal enjoyment and the importance of keeping celebrations meaningful.

13. Should Families Stop Pretending That Santa Claus Is Real?

For many children, believing in Santa Claus is one of the most magical parts of Christmas. However, some people argue that encouraging this belief involves deliberately misleading children and may eventually damage their trust in adults. Others believe that imagination, storytelling and childhood wonder are more important than literal truth.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an opinion article arguing whether parents should continue the tradition of Santa Claus or explain from an early age that he is a fictional character. Consider honesty, imagination, family relationships and the emotional significance of childhood traditions.

14. Should Christmas Be Celebrated on a Different Day?

Christmas Day falls on 25 December in many countries, but not everyone celebrates on that date. Some Christian traditions observe Christmas in January, while families separated by work, travel or personal circumstances may celebrate whenever they can be together. Does the date itself matter, or is the meaning of the celebration more important?

Persuasive writing challenge: Argue whether families should feel free to move their Christmas celebrations to any convenient date without social pressure to follow the traditional calendar. Consider cultural identity, religious significance, family responsibilities and the value of shared celebrations.

15. Should Christmas Cards Be Replaced with Digital Messages?

Sending Christmas cards has long been a way to maintain friendships, express appreciation and reconnect with distant relatives. However, traditional cards require paper, postage and transportation, while digital messages can be delivered instantly and often cost nothing. Some people argue that electronic greetings are more practical, while others believe they lack the personal touch of handwritten cards.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive letter to a newspaper arguing whether traditional Christmas cards should be phased out in favour of digital greetings. Consider environmental concerns, convenience, accessibility and the emotional value of receiving something handwritten.

16. Should Christmas Eve Become a Public Holiday?

For many families, Christmas Eve is spent travelling, preparing meals, wrapping presents and organising celebrations. Yet many people are still expected to work, sometimes until late in the evening. Supporters of an additional public holiday argue that everyone deserves more time to prepare and relax, while opponents highlight the financial consequences for businesses and essential services.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive speech arguing whether Christmas Eve should become an official public holiday in countries where it is currently a normal working day. Consider workers' rights, economic consequences, family time and the needs of essential workers.

17. Should Families Abandon Traditional Christmas Dinners?

Roast turkey, potatoes, vegetables and elaborate desserts remain familiar features of Christmas dinner in many households. However, preparing a traditional festive meal can be expensive, time-consuming and stressful, particularly when family members have different dietary requirements or preferences. Would Christmas be more enjoyable if everyone simply ate their favourite food?

Persuasive writing challenge: Argue whether families should abandon the expectation of serving a traditional Christmas dinner. Consider the importance of shared rituals, financial pressure, personal choice and whether food traditions bring families together or create unnecessary stress.

18. Should Public Christmas Celebrations Be Inclusive of All Winter Festivals?

Christmas markets, public light displays and community celebrations are common features of December. However, communities often include people who celebrate Hanukkah, Yule, other religious or cultural festivals, or no religious holidays at all. Some argue that public celebrations should reflect this diversity, while others believe traditional Christmas events should retain their distinctive identity.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive proposal to your local council arguing whether public Christmas celebrations should be expanded to recognise a wider range of winter festivals and traditions. Consider community identity, cultural representation, public funding and the importance of inclusion.

19. Should Families Be Expected to Spend Christmas Together?

Christmas is frequently portrayed as a time when families should gather, exchange gifts and enjoy one another's company. However, not everyone has positive family relationships, and some people would prefer to spend the holiday with friends, partners or alone. Does the expectation of family togetherness create unnecessary pressure?

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive essay arguing whether society places too much importance on spending Christmas with family. Consider personal wellbeing, social expectations, different family circumstances and the right to create individual traditions.

20. Should Christmas Traditions Be Taught in Schools?

Christmas traditions vary considerably across countries and cultures, from festive foods and gift-giving customs to religious ceremonies and community celebrations. Learning about these practices could help students understand cultural diversity and historical change. However, some argue that schools should concentrate on academic subjects rather than devoting additional time to seasonal traditions.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive letter to your headteacher arguing whether schools should introduce lessons exploring Christmas traditions from around the world. Consider cultural understanding, curriculum priorities, religious education and the benefits of learning about unfamiliar customs.

3. Christmas Gifts, Shopping & Consumerism

Is Christmas really about giving, or has it become an excuse to spend money? From extravagant presents and festive advertising campaigns to unwanted gifts and the pressure to keep up with social media trends, Christmas shopping raises plenty of questions about generosity, fairness and consumer culture.

These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics encourage students to examine the influence of advertising, question gift-giving expectations and consider the social and environmental consequences of festive spending. With challenges ranging from podcast scripts and television debates to advertising campaigns and newspaper editorials, students can practise adapting their persuasive techniques to different audiences and purposes.

21. Has Christmas Become Too Commercialised?

Christmas advertisements begin appearing months before December, retailers compete to offer increasingly elaborate festive experiences, and social media feeds fill with gift guides, luxury decorations and expensive celebrations. Some argue that commercialisation has overshadowed the traditional values of generosity, kindness and togetherness. Others believe that shopping, gift-giving and festive spending are simply enjoyable parts of modern Christmas celebrations.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a 5-minute podcast episode titled Has Christmas Lost Its Meaning? Present a clear argument about whether commercialisation has damaged the festive season. Include a compelling opening, examples of commercial influence, a response to an opposing viewpoint and a memorable concluding statement.

22. Should Parents Set a Strict Spending Limit on Christmas Presents?

Some children receive hundreds of pounds' worth of Christmas presents, while others receive only a handful of carefully chosen gifts. Supporters of spending limits argue that expensive presents encourage materialism and create unrealistic expectations. However, others believe families should be free to spend their own money however they choose.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive blog post arguing whether parents should introduce a strict Christmas present budget for their children. Consider financial responsibility, fairness, family circumstances and whether the value of a gift should be measured by its price.

23. Should Christmas Advertisements Aimed at Children Be Banned?

Toy manufacturers and retailers invest heavily in Christmas advertising designed to capture children's attention. Colourful commercials, celebrity endorsements and online influencers can make particular toys seem essential, creating pressure on parents to purchase expensive or difficult-to-find products. But is advertising simply informing consumers about available products, or is it deliberately exploiting children's emotions?

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal petition calling for stricter regulations on Christmas advertising aimed at children, or opposing such restrictions. Include a clear demand, three persuasive reasons supporting your position and a direct appeal encouraging readers to sign.

24. Is Regifting an Unwanted Christmas Present Acceptable?

Imagine receiving a Christmas present that you already own, dislike or will never use. Is it perfectly reasonable to give it to someone else, or does regifting show a lack of appreciation for the original giver? Some believe regifting reduces waste and ensures unwanted items find a useful home, while others consider it dishonest or disrespectful.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a humorous but convincing opinion column for a lifestyle magazine titled In Defence of Regifting or Why Regifting Is the Ultimate Christmas Insult. Use wit, rhetorical questions and relatable examples to persuade readers to adopt your viewpoint.

25. Should Shops Be Allowed to Open on Christmas Day?

For many people, Christmas Day is one of the few occasions when shops close and workers can spend uninterrupted time with their families. However, not everyone celebrates Christmas, and some employees may welcome the opportunity to earn additional money. Others argue that consumers should have access to essential goods regardless of the date.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a televised debate between a retail business owner, a shop worker, a trade union representative and a customer. Give each participant a distinct position on Christmas Day trading, include persuasive opening statements and develop at least two exchanges in which speakers directly challenge opposing arguments.

26. Should Secret Santa Replace Traditional Christmas Gift-Giving?

Buying individual presents for every family member, friend or colleague can become expensive and stressful. Secret Santa offers an alternative: each participant purchases one gift for a randomly assigned person, often within an agreed spending limit. However, critics argue that this arrangement removes the personal meaning of choosing presents for loved ones.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a persuasive presentation proposing that your family or friendship group adopt Secret Santa instead of exchanging individual gifts. Explain how the system would work, address potential objections and convince your audience that your approach would improve Christmas celebrations.

27. Should Influencers Be Required to Label All Gifted Christmas Products?

During November and December, social media influencers frequently share Christmas gift guides, product recommendations and festive shopping hauls. Some receive free products or payment from brands, potentially influencing which items they promote. Although advertising disclosure rules already exist in many places, questions remain about whether audiences always recognise promotional content.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a social media awareness campaign encouraging greater transparency in festive influencer marketing. Write five connected posts that explain the issue, use persuasive language and encourage followers to question the recommendations they encounter online. Finish with a clear call to action.

28. Are Handmade Christmas Gifts Better Than Shop-Bought Presents?

A handmade Christmas gift might take hours of thought, planning and effort, while a shop-bought present can sometimes be purchased in minutes. Supporters of handmade gifts argue that personal effort demonstrates genuine care and affection. Others believe that a carefully chosen purchased gift can be equally thoughtful, particularly when the recipient has specific interests or needs.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive feature article for a Christmas lifestyle website arguing whether handmade gifts are more meaningful than shop-bought presents. Consider personal effort, practicality, creativity, cost and the importance of understanding what the recipient actually wants.

29. Should Retailers Be Banned from Using Artificial Scarcity During Christmas Sales?

Messages such as "Only three left!", "Sale ends in ten minutes!" and "Selling fast!" are common features of online Christmas shopping. These marketing techniques can create urgency and encourage customers to make purchases before carefully considering whether they need the product. Retailers argue that genuine stock warnings help shoppers make informed decisions, but critics question whether some urgency tactics manipulate consumers.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an open letter to a major online retailer demanding an end to misleading Christmas sales tactics, or defending the use of genuine limited-time offers. Use specific examples, logical reasoning and persuasive language to convince the company to reconsider or maintain its approach.

30. Should Christmas Gifts Be Replaced with Experiences?

Instead of purchasing toys, clothing or electronic devices, some families choose to give experiences such as concert tickets, theatre visits, cooking classes or days out. Supporters argue that experiences create lasting memories and reduce unnecessary possessions. However, others believe physical presents offer greater excitement, practical value and opportunities for long-term enjoyment.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a persuasive advertising campaign promoting either experience-based Christmas gifts or traditional physical presents. Write a memorable slogan, a 30-second television advertisement script and a short promotional message. Use emotive language and carefully chosen examples to convince your target audience that your approach offers the better Christmas gift.

4. Christmas Food: Festive Arguments & Controversies

Is Christmas dinner really the most important meal of the year? Should Brussels sprouts be banned from festive menus? And is it acceptable to serve pizza instead of a traditional roast? Few subjects inspire stronger opinions than Christmas food, especially when family traditions, personal preferences and dietary choices collide.

These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics turn familiar festive food controversies into opportunities for lively arguments, creative writing tasks and classroom debates. From humorous restaurant reviews and television cooking competitions to serious discussions about food waste and dietary inclusion, students can explore how persuasive language changes depending on their audience, purpose and chosen format.

31. Is Christmas Dinner the Most Overrated Meal of the Year?

Families spend hours preparing elaborate Christmas dinners, often involving multiple courses, complicated recipes and expensive ingredients. Yet some people argue that the traditional Christmas meal is more stressful than enjoyable, particularly when the food is no different from an ordinary Sunday roast. Others insist that the preparation, anticipation and shared experience make Christmas dinner special.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a provocative food column for a national newspaper titled Christmas Dinner: A Feast Worth Celebrating or an Overrated Tradition? Use humour, rhetorical questions and convincing examples to persuade readers that Christmas dinner either deserves its reputation or has become unnecessarily extravagant.

32. Should Brussels Sprouts Be Banned from Christmas Dinner?

Brussels sprouts are one of the most controversial vegetables on the Christmas table. Some people consider them an essential part of a traditional festive meal, while others complain about their bitter flavour, distinctive smell and tendency to be overcooked. But should one unpopular vegetable be allowed to ruin an otherwise delicious celebration?

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a dramatic television courtroom scene titled The People vs Brussels Sprouts. Present opening arguments from the prosecution and defence, introduce two witnesses with opposing opinions and finish with a persuasive closing statement arguing whether Brussels sprouts deserve a permanent place on the Christmas menu.

33. Should Schools Be Required to Offer a Traditional Christmas Lunch?

Many schools organise special Christmas lunches featuring roast dinners, festive desserts and seasonal decorations. However, not every student enjoys traditional Christmas food, and some have religious, cultural or dietary requirements that make certain dishes unsuitable. Should schools prioritise familiar festive traditions or offer a wider range of choices?

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal proposal to your school's catering team recommending changes to the Christmas lunch menu. Argue whether traditional meals should remain the main option or be replaced with a more flexible festive menu. Include practical suggestions, anticipated costs and a response to possible objections.

34. Is It Acceptable to Order a Takeaway for Christmas Dinner?

Christmas dinner is often associated with home cooking, family recipes and hours spent preparing food together. However, ordering a takeaway could eliminate stress, reduce washing up and allow everyone to spend more time enjoying the holiday. Critics argue that abandoning the traditional meal removes an important part of Christmas.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a festive radio phone-in show debating whether ordering a takeaway on Christmas Day is a brilliant modern solution or a betrayal of Christmas tradition. Include a presenter, three callers with different perspectives and a concluding argument that attempts to persuade listeners.

35. Should Supermarkets Be Required to Donate Unsold Christmas Food?

During the festive season, supermarkets stock large quantities of seasonal food, including fresh produce, desserts and luxury Christmas products. When these items remain unsold, some may become food waste despite people in the community struggling to afford basic groceries. However, donating surplus food involves challenges relating to storage, transportation, food safety and distribution.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an open letter to the chief executive of a major supermarket arguing whether retailers should be legally required to donate suitable unsold Christmas food to charities. Support your position with ethical reasoning, practical considerations and a clear proposal for reducing festive food waste.

36. Should Families Stop Pressuring People to Eat Traditional Christmas Foods?

Christmas celebrations often involve familiar dishes that relatives expect everyone to enjoy. Children may be encouraged to finish vegetables they dislike, guests may feel obliged to accept second helpings, and people with different dietary preferences can face uncomfortable questions. Some believe sharing traditional food strengthens family relationships, while others argue that personal choices should always be respected.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive blog post titled My Christmas Dinner, My Choice! arguing whether family members should stop commenting on what others eat during festive celebrations. Consider personal autonomy, hospitality, family expectations and the difference between encouraging someone to try a dish and pressuring them to eat it.

37. Should Christmas Food Advertisements Be More Realistic?

Christmas food advertisements frequently feature enormous dining tables, perfectly roasted turkeys, elaborate desserts and smiling families enjoying extravagant celebrations. While these images create excitement and encourage spending, they can also promote unrealistic expectations about what Christmas should look like. Some consumers appreciate the fantasy, while others believe festive advertising encourages unnecessary expense and comparison.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a two-minute television commentary script arguing whether Christmas food advertisements should portray more realistic family meals. Include examples of common advertising techniques, explain their influence on consumers and persuade viewers to reconsider what makes a successful Christmas celebration.

38. Is Christmas Pudding an Outdated Tradition?

Christmas pudding has been associated with British festive celebrations for generations, yet its rich fruit flavours, dense texture and lengthy preparation process do not appeal to everyone. Some families continue serving it because of tradition rather than genuine enjoyment, while others believe abandoning the dessert would mean losing an important piece of culinary heritage.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a humorous restaurant review evaluating whether Christmas pudding deserves to remain the centrepiece of festive desserts. Compare it with modern alternatives, use vivid descriptive language to influence your readers and finish with a decisive recommendation.

39. Should Christmas Meals Be Entirely Vegetarian?

Traditional Christmas dinners often feature turkey, beef, ham or other meat-based dishes. However, vegetarian Christmas meals are becoming increasingly familiar, and supporters argue that plant-based celebrations can reduce environmental impact and avoid concerns about animal welfare. Opponents believe that people should be free to follow their own dietary traditions without restrictions.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a panel discussion for a television food programme debating whether families should consider serving an entirely vegetarian Christmas dinner. Include a vegetarian chef, a traditional cook, an environmental campaigner and a family representative. Give each speaker convincing arguments and include direct responses to opposing viewpoints.

40. Should Christmas Food Be Available All Year Round?

Mince pies, Christmas puddings, festive chocolates and seasonal sandwiches often appear in shops months before December, only to disappear shortly after the holiday. Some people argue that customers should be able to purchase their favourite festive foods whenever they want. Others believe seasonal availability makes these products more exciting and preserves their association with Christmas.

Persuasive writing challenge: Develop a persuasive marketing pitch for a supermarket deciding whether to sell Christmas foods throughout the year. Present your recommendation as a short business proposal, including a memorable campaign slogan, three supporting arguments and a response to concerns about customer demand, costs or the loss of festive excitement.

5. Christmas Movies, Music & Entertainment

Is Home Alone really a Christmas classic? Should radio stations stop playing festive songs in November? And does every Christmas film need a happy ending? From nostalgic movies and endlessly repeated songs to school concerts and celebrity Christmas specials, festive entertainment inspires surprisingly passionate opinions.

These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics encourage students to explore the influence of popular culture, question entertainment traditions and defend their personal tastes. Through film reviews, podcast scripts, television debates and creative media campaigns, students can practise constructing convincing arguments while considering how entertainment shapes our expectations of Christmas.

41. Is Home Alone the Greatest Christmas Film of All Time?

For decades, Home Alone has remained a festive favourite, combining slapstick comedy, family conflict and a surprisingly heartfelt message about belonging. However, some viewers argue that its popularity depends more on nostalgia than exceptional storytelling, while others believe newer Christmas films offer stronger characters, more original plots and more meaningful messages.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a film critic's opinion column arguing whether Home Alone deserves to be considered the greatest Christmas film ever made. Compare its humour, characters, themes and lasting cultural influence with at least one other festive film. Use confident evaluative language and convincing examples to persuade readers to agree with your verdict.

42. Should Radio Stations Be Banned from Playing Christmas Music Before December?

For some listeners, hearing the first Christmas song of the year signals the beginning of a magical season. For others, weeks of repetitive festive playlists become irritating long before Christmas Day arrives. Radio stations must balance the preferences of enthusiastic Christmas fans with those who would rather wait until December.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a lively five-minute radio debate between two presenters who disagree about when Christmas music should begin. Include persuasive opening arguments, humorous exchanges, direct challenges and a final appeal asking listeners to support one position.

43. Are Modern Christmas Films Too Predictable?

A busy professional returns to a picturesque hometown, meets an unexpectedly charming stranger and discovers the true meaning of Christmas. Familiar storylines like this appear in countless festive romantic comedies. Some viewers enjoy the comforting predictability, while others argue that Christmas films have become repetitive and unimaginative.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a film-review podcast episode titled Have Christmas Movies Run Out of Ideas? Argue whether familiar festive formulas are an essential part of their appeal or evidence that filmmakers need to take greater creative risks. Use examples, comparisons and a persuasive final recommendation.

44. Should Streaming Services Release Christmas Films Throughout the Year?

Streaming platforms frequently promote Christmas films during November and December, when audiences are most likely to seek festive entertainment. However, some viewers enjoy watching Christmas movies in the middle of summer, while others believe seasonal releases create anticipation and make the experience more special.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a business proposal to a fictional streaming service arguing whether it should release and promote Christmas films throughout the year or concentrate its festive content into a limited seasonal collection. Consider audience demand, marketing opportunities, viewing habits and the value of exclusivity.

45. Should Christmas Films Always Have Happy Endings?

Christmas films often conclude with reunited families, restored friendships, romantic declarations or unexpected acts of generosity. These uplifting endings reflect the season's association with hope and happiness. However, some critics argue that constantly resolving every conflict creates unrealistic expectations and prevents filmmakers from exploring more complicated emotions.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an editorial for an entertainment magazine arguing whether Christmas films should always end happily. Consider the purpose of festive entertainment, audience expectations and whether bittersweet or tragic endings can communicate equally powerful messages about love, loss and human connection.

46. Should Schools Stop Showing Christmas Films During the Final Week of Term?

Watching Christmas films has become a familiar end-of-term tradition in many classrooms. Supporters argue that festive screenings reward students for their hard work and create a relaxed atmosphere before the holidays. Critics believe that spending several lessons watching films offers limited educational value and reduces opportunities for more meaningful activities.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a persuasive presentation for a school leadership meeting arguing whether Christmas film screenings should remain part of end-of-term celebrations. Suggest possible alternatives, respond to concerns about lost learning time and explain how your preferred approach would benefit students.

47. Are Christmas Songs from Previous Generations Better Than Modern Festive Music?

Classic Christmas songs continue to dominate festive playlists, despite new releases appearing every year. Some listeners believe older songs possess memorable melodies, meaningful lyrics and a nostalgic quality that modern music struggles to recreate. Others argue that contemporary artists deserve greater recognition and that musical tastes should evolve.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a provocative music blog post titled Christmas Music Was Better in the Old Days — Or Was It? Compare classic and contemporary festive songs, evaluate their originality and emotional appeal, and persuade readers that one era deserves greater recognition. Include at least one counterargument to strengthen your position.

48. Should Celebrities Be Paid Millions to Appear in Christmas Advertisements?

Major retailers sometimes recruit famous actors, musicians and public figures to appear in elaborate Christmas advertising campaigns. Supporters argue that celebrity appearances attract attention, create memorable entertainment and generate valuable sales. Critics question whether enormous advertising budgets are justified during a season supposedly associated with generosity and social responsibility.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a television current-affairs debate exploring whether retailers should spend large sums on celebrity Christmas advertisements. Include a marketing executive, a celebrity representative, a consumer campaigner and a charity spokesperson. Give each participant a clear position and develop exchanges that challenge the assumptions behind opposing arguments.

49. Should Christmas Television Specials Be Reserved for Christmas Day?

Christmas television specials have traditionally brought families together for shared entertainment, often becoming memorable parts of the holiday itself. However, streaming services and on-demand platforms allow viewers to watch programmes whenever they choose. Some believe releasing festive specials early spoils the anticipation, while others argue that audiences should control their own viewing schedules.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an open letter to a television broadcaster arguing whether major Christmas specials should premiere exclusively on Christmas Day or be released earlier for on-demand viewing. Consider family traditions, accessibility, audience expectations and the changing nature of television entertainment.

50. Is Die Hard Really a Christmas Film?

Few festive film arguments are as persistent as the debate surrounding Die Hard. Although the action takes place during a Christmas party and includes seasonal music and decorations, the film is primarily known for its explosions, violence and action sequences. Some viewers insist that its Christmas setting makes it a legitimate festive classic, while others argue that a Christmas film should place the holiday at the centre of its story.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a mock courtroom script titled The Case of Die Hard: Christmas Classic or Action Impostor? Present arguments from the prosecution and defence, call witnesses to examine the film's setting, themes and storyline, and deliver a persuasive closing statement explaining why it should either be admitted to or permanently excluded from the Christmas film collection.

6. Christmas Ethics: Kindness, Charity & Responsibility

Christmas is often described as the season of goodwill, generosity and compassion. But does the festive season actually make people kinder, or does it simply encourage temporary acts of generosity? Should charitable giving be expected, and do individuals, businesses and governments have a greater responsibility to support vulnerable people during the holidays?

These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics explore the ethical questions behind festive celebrations, encouraging students to examine social responsibility, fairness, generosity and the difference between good intentions and meaningful action. From charity campaigns and political speeches to investigative podcasts and public debates, each challenge offers opportunities to construct thoughtful arguments, evaluate opposing perspectives and use persuasive language to advocate for change.

51. Should Everyone Be Expected to Donate to Charity at Christmas?

Christmas charity appeals encourage people to donate money, food, clothing and gifts to those experiencing hardship. Supporters argue that festive giving strengthens communities and reminds people to consider those less fortunate. However, others believe charitable donations should always remain a personal choice, particularly when families may already be struggling financially.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an opinion article for a national newspaper arguing whether society places too much pressure on people to donate to charity during Christmas. Consider personal responsibility, financial circumstances, the importance of generosity and whether charitable giving loses its meaning when people feel obliged to participate.

52. Should Companies Be Required to Give a Percentage of Their Christmas Profits to Charity?

For many retailers, Christmas is the most profitable period of the year, with businesses generating substantial revenue from festive shopping. Some argue that companies benefiting from Christmas spending have a moral responsibility to support their communities. Others believe businesses already contribute through employment, taxation and voluntary charitable partnerships.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a persuasive speech for a fictional parliamentary debate proposing that large retailers donate a fixed percentage of their Christmas profits to charitable causes. Support your argument with ethical reasoning, anticipate objections about business costs and explain how your proposal could benefit society.

53. Is Volunteering More Valuable Than Donating Money?

Some people spend Christmas volunteering at food banks, community kitchens, hospitals or charitable organisations. Others prefer to contribute financially, allowing charities to purchase essential supplies and employ trained professionals. While volunteering offers personal involvement, financial donations can sometimes provide greater flexibility and reach.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a podcast episode titled Time or Money: What Is the Greatest Gift? Argue whether volunteering or financial donations make a more meaningful contribution during Christmas. Compare their practical benefits, acknowledge their limitations and persuade listeners to reconsider how they support charitable causes.

54. Should Nobody Have to Spend Christmas Day Alone?

Christmas advertising, films and social traditions frequently portray the holiday as a time for family gatherings and shared celebrations. However, many people experience loneliness during the festive season, including older adults, people living away from family and those experiencing difficult personal circumstances. Some believe communities should organise events and support networks to ensure everyone has the opportunity for companionship, while others argue that spending Christmas alone can be a positive personal choice.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an open letter to your local council proposing a community initiative to reduce unwanted loneliness at Christmas. Explain why the issue deserves attention, suggest practical solutions and address how your proposal would respect people who genuinely prefer to celebrate alone.

55. Should Children Be Encouraged to Give Away Some of Their Christmas Presents?

Many children receive toys, games, books and other presents during the festive season, while others may receive very little. Some parents encourage their children to donate unwanted toys or choose a new present to give to someone in need. Supporters believe this teaches generosity and empathy, while critics argue that children should not feel guilty about enjoying gifts they have received.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive parenting blog post arguing whether children should be encouraged to donate some of their Christmas presents. Consider emotional development, personal ownership, generosity and the difference between encouraging kindness and creating feelings of obligation.

56. Should Governments Provide Extra Financial Support to Families at Christmas?

The festive season can create additional financial pressure through increased heating costs, school holidays, travel expenses and social expectations surrounding gifts and celebrations. Some argue that governments should provide targeted financial assistance to families experiencing hardship. Others believe public funds should prioritise year-round support rather than seasonal payments.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a televised political debate between a government minister, an opposition representative, a charity worker and a parent experiencing financial difficulties. Each speaker should defend a different position on Christmas financial assistance, challenge opposing arguments and propose practical solutions to seasonal hardship.

57. Should Christmas Charity Campaigns Stop Using Distressing Images?

Charitable organisations sometimes use emotional photographs, personal stories and distressing images to encourage donations during Christmas. These campaigns can raise awareness of serious problems and inspire immediate action. However, critics argue that some fundraising materials exploit suffering, undermine dignity or encourage donors to respond emotionally without understanding the wider issues.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an editorial for a media ethics magazine arguing whether charities should restrict their use of distressing images in Christmas fundraising campaigns. Consider the effectiveness of emotional appeals, the dignity of people featured in advertisements and whether ethical concerns should outweigh potential fundraising benefits.

58. Should People Be Encouraged to Perform Random Acts of Kindness Throughout December?

Advent calendars traditionally count down the days until Christmas with pictures, chocolates or small gifts. In recent years, some families and schools have introduced kindness calendars, encouraging participants to complete a generous act each day. Supporters believe these activities develop empathy and create positive habits, while others question whether kindness should be organised into a daily challenge.

Persuasive writing challenge: Design a persuasive campaign encouraging your school or community to participate in a December kindness challenge. Write a campaign slogan, a short promotional speech and five social media posts explaining why small acts of generosity can make a meaningful difference. Address the argument that kindness should be spontaneous rather than scheduled.

59. Should Essential Workers Receive Double Pay on Christmas Day?

While many people spend Christmas Day relaxing with family, nurses, carers, emergency responders, hospitality employees and other essential workers may be required to work. Some believe these employees deserve significantly higher wages for sacrificing their holiday, while others argue that increased staffing costs could place additional pressure on already stretched services.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal letter to a government representative arguing whether employees required to work on Christmas Day should receive double pay. Consider fairness, financial consequences, workers' rights and the importance of maintaining essential services. Include a counterargument and a realistic proposal for implementing your position.

60. Does Christmas Encourage Genuine Kindness or Performative Generosity?

During December, social media fills with charitable challenges, donation announcements, volunteer photographs and stories of extraordinary generosity. Some believe sharing good deeds inspires others to act and raises awareness of important causes. Critics argue that public displays of kindness can become opportunities for attention, personal branding or social approval rather than genuine compassion.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for an investigative podcast episode titled Christmas Kindness: Compassion or Performance? Examine whether publicising charitable acts strengthens their impact or undermines their sincerity. Include contrasting viewpoints, examples of social media behaviour and a persuasive conclusion explaining whether the motivation behind an act of kindness matters as much as its consequences.

7. Christmas and the Environment: Sustainability, Waste & Festive Choices

Christmas may be the most wonderful time of the year, but it can also be one of the most wasteful. From discarded wrapping paper and unwanted presents to excessive packaging, energy-hungry decorations and mountains of leftover food, festive celebrations raise important questions about our responsibility to the environment.

Can Christmas remain magical without encouraging unnecessary consumption? Should governments introduce restrictions on wasteful festive products, or should individuals be free to celebrate however they choose? These ten Christmas persuasive writing topics challenge students to examine the environmental consequences of familiar traditions and consider whether sustainability should take priority over convenience, enjoyment and personal choice.

Through environmental campaigns, persuasive speeches, newspaper editorials, television debates and advertising pitches, students can practise using evidence, emotional appeals and counterarguments to influence different audiences.

61. Should Real Christmas Trees Be Banned to Protect the Environment?

Every December, millions of households choose between real Christmas trees and artificial alternatives. Supporters of real trees argue that responsibly grown trees absorb carbon dioxide while growing, can support wildlife habitats and are biodegradable when properly disposed of. Others prefer artificial trees because they can be reused for many years and do not require a new tree to be grown, harvested and transported each Christmas.

However, artificial trees are often manufactured from plastic and metal, making their environmental impact more complicated than it first appears.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an environmental newspaper editorial arguing whether real Christmas trees should be banned, encouraged or treated as an equally valid alternative to artificial trees. Consider production, transportation, disposal and long-term environmental consequences. Use logical reasoning and address at least one argument that challenges your position.

62. Should Glitter Be Banned from Christmas Decorations?

Glitter-covered Christmas cards, sparkling ornaments and festive craft projects may look beautiful, but conventional plastic glitter can contribute to microplastic pollution. Some environmental campaigners argue that decorative glitter is an unnecessary source of plastic waste, while others believe banning it would be an excessive response to a relatively small part of a much larger problem.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a persuasive social media campaign calling for a ban on conventional plastic glitter in Christmas decorations, or defending consumers' right to use it. Write a campaign slogan, four connected social media posts and a short video script. Use a combination of environmental reasoning, memorable language and a clear call to action.

63. Should Christmas Lights Be Switched Off After Midnight?

Festive light displays transform ordinary streets into colourful winter attractions, bringing enjoyment to residents and visitors. However, elaborate decorations can increase electricity consumption, contribute to light pollution and disturb neighbours or wildlife. Some argue that Christmas lights should be subject to strict overnight restrictions, while others believe households should decide when to switch off their own decorations.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a speech for a local council meeting arguing whether residential Christmas lights should be switched off after midnight. Consider energy consumption, community enjoyment, environmental responsibility and the practical difficulties of enforcing restrictions. Finish with a persuasive proposal that balances competing interests.

64. Should Wrapping Paper Be Replaced with Reusable Gift Packaging?

Beautifully wrapped presents are an important part of Christmas for many families, but discarded wrapping paper can create substantial waste. Some varieties contain plastic coatings, glitter or metallic finishes that make recycling difficult. Reusable fabric wraps, gift bags and recyclable paper offer alternatives, although they may involve additional costs or changes to familiar traditions.

Persuasive writing challenge: Develop a persuasive advertising campaign for a fictional company selling reusable Christmas gift packaging. Write a 45-second television advertisement, a memorable slogan and a short promotional description. Convince customers that reusable packaging can be practical, attractive and environmentally responsible without sacrificing the excitement of opening presents.

65. Should Supermarkets Be Banned from Selling Excessively Packaged Christmas Products?

Christmas chocolates, luxury biscuits, gift sets and seasonal foods are frequently sold in elaborate boxes, plastic trays and decorative containers. While attractive packaging can protect products and make them suitable for gifting, critics argue that excessive materials create unnecessary waste and encourage consumers to pay more for presentation than substance.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a television consumer affairs debate between a supermarket executive, an environmental campaigner, a packaging designer and a concerned shopper. Explore whether governments should regulate excessive Christmas packaging. Give each participant a distinct argument and include direct challenges, rebuttals and a final recommendation.

66. Should Families Introduce a Zero-Waste Christmas Challenge?

A zero-waste Christmas might involve buying second-hand gifts, avoiding disposable decorations, reducing food waste and replacing single-use wrapping paper with reusable alternatives. Supporters believe these changes encourage creativity, reduce unnecessary consumption and help families develop more sustainable habits. Critics argue that attempting to eliminate waste completely can be expensive, impractical and stressful.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive blog post titled Could You Survive a Zero-Waste Christmas? Argue whether families should attempt a zero-waste celebration, even if they cannot eliminate every source of waste. Include practical examples, respond to concerns about cost and convenience, and persuade readers to reconsider at least three familiar festive habits.

67. Should Christmas Markets Be Required to Ban Single-Use Plastics?

Christmas markets attract visitors with seasonal food, hot drinks, handmade gifts and festive entertainment. However, disposable cups, plastic cutlery, food containers and shopping bags can generate large quantities of rubbish. Reusable alternatives may reduce waste, but they can also introduce additional cleaning requirements, costs and logistical challenges for small businesses.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal proposal to the organisers of a local Christmas market recommending whether single-use plastics should be banned. Present three persuasive arguments, acknowledge the challenges faced by independent traders and suggest realistic alternatives that could make the event more environmentally responsible.

68. Should People Be Discouraged from Travelling Long Distances for Christmas?

Christmas is one of the busiest travel periods of the year, with families travelling by car, train and plane to spend time together. Long-distance journeys can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, particularly when air travel is involved. However, discouraging travel could prevent families separated by work, education or geography from sharing an important celebration.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a current affairs podcast episode titled Home for Christmas: Is Festive Travel Worth the Environmental Cost? Examine whether people should reduce long-distance Christmas journeys or whether family connections justify the environmental impact. Use contrasting examples, acknowledge emotional considerations and finish with a persuasive argument supporting your position.

69. Should Artificial Snow Be Banned from Christmas Displays?

Artificial snow is used in shop windows, festive events, photography and Christmas decorations to create the appearance of a winter wonderland. Some products contain plastics or other materials that may create environmental problems if released outdoors or disposed of improperly. However, artificial snow also allows communities in warmer climates to recreate familiar festive scenes without relying on natural snowfall.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an open letter to a major shopping centre arguing whether artificial snow should be prohibited from its Christmas displays. Consider environmental risks, alternative materials, commercial interests and the importance of festive experiences. Use emotive language alongside practical reasoning to persuade management to adopt your recommendation.

70. Is an Environmentally Friendly Christmas More Important Than a Traditional Christmas?

For generations, Christmas celebrations have included decorated trees, elaborate meals, wrapped presents, festive travel and illuminated homes. Increasing awareness of environmental issues has encouraged some families to rethink these customs. Supporters of sustainable celebrations argue that traditions should evolve when their environmental consequences become clear. Others believe individuals should be free to preserve meaningful customs without feeling guilty about their choices.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write the closing argument for a formal classroom debate on the motion: This House Believes That Environmental Responsibility Should Take Priority Over Christmas Traditions.

Your speech should summarise your strongest arguments, challenge the opposing team's position and appeal to the audience's values. Finish with a powerful concluding statement that encourages listeners to reconsider what makes Christmas truly meaningful.

8. Winter Weather, Snow Days & Seasonal Debates

Should schools close whenever it snows? Is winter really the worst season of the year? And should building the perfect snowman be considered a competitive sport? From icy playgrounds and unexpected snow days to winter holidays and freezing temperatures, the colder months provide plenty of opportunities for persuasive writing and lively classroom discussions.

These ten winter persuasive writing topics encourage students to consider the practical, social and environmental challenges of the season while exploring some more entertaining winter controversies. Through newspaper editorials, television debates, podcast scripts, formal proposals and imaginative advertising campaigns, students can practise adapting their arguments to different audiences and purposes.

Whether defending the importance of snow days or arguing that winter is unfairly criticised, each question invites students to develop a clear position, consider opposing viewpoints and support their opinions with convincing reasoning.

71. Should Schools Close Whenever It Snows?

For many students, waking up to a blanket of snow brings the exciting possibility of an unexpected day off school. Snow days provide opportunities for outdoor activities, relaxation and spontaneous family time. However, school closures can disrupt learning, create childcare difficulties and place additional pressure on working parents. In areas where snowfall is common, closing schools for every snow shower might be impractical.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a newspaper editorial arguing whether schools should automatically close when snow is forecast or remain open unless conditions become dangerous. Consider student safety, transport difficulties, educational disruption and the importance of allowing children to enjoy occasional snow days. Include a counterargument and propose a reasonable school closure policy.

72. Is Winter the Worst Season of the Year?

Shorter days, freezing temperatures, icy pavements and unpredictable weather make winter an unpopular season for some people. Others appreciate its cosy evenings, beautiful landscapes, festive celebrations and opportunities for winter sports. But when compared with the warmth of summer, the colours of autumn and the fresh beginnings of spring, does winter deserve its reputation as the most miserable season?

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a humorous podcast episode titled Winter: Magical Wonderland or Four Months of Misery? Argue whether winter is the best or worst season of the year. Use entertaining comparisons, rhetorical questions and exaggerated but recognisable examples to persuade listeners to agree with your verdict.

73. Should Students Be Allowed to Stay Indoors During Winter Break Times?

During the colder months, students may be expected to spend their breaks outside, even when temperatures are low and the playground is wet or uncomfortable. Supporters of outdoor breaks argue that fresh air, exercise and physical activity benefit students' wellbeing. Others believe children should be able to choose whether to remain indoors, particularly during unpleasant weather.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal letter to your headteacher arguing whether students should have access to indoor break spaces throughout winter. Consider physical health, student wellbeing, supervision requirements and the importance of giving students some control over their free time.

74. Should Snowball Fights Be Banned in Public Parks?

Snowball fights are a familiar winter activity, offering opportunities for outdoor play, laughter and friendly competition. However, poorly aimed snowballs can cause injuries, particularly when they contain ice or are thrown at people who do not want to participate. Some argue that banning snowball fights would protect public safety, while others believe sensible rules are better than unnecessary restrictions.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a television debate between a local councillor, a parent, a teenager and a public safety representative discussing whether snowball fights should be prohibited in public parks. Give each participant a clear position, include direct challenges and rebuttals, and conclude with a proposed solution that balances safety with the freedom to enjoy winter activities.

75. Should Winter School Uniform Rules Be Relaxed?

Many schools require students to follow strict uniform policies throughout the year, even when temperatures drop significantly. Some students argue that they should be allowed to wear additional layers, warmer footwear or alternative clothing during winter. Others believe consistent uniform standards promote equality, discipline and a sense of belonging.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive proposal for your school council recommending changes to winter uniform regulations. Explain which items should be permitted, why the changes would benefit students and how the school could maintain reasonable dress standards. Address possible objections relating to appearance, cost and fairness.

76. Should Towns Spend More Money on Winter Festivals?

Winter festivals, outdoor ice rinks, illuminated trails and seasonal markets can attract visitors, support local businesses and bring communities together during the darkest months. However, organising these events can be expensive, particularly when councils are already facing difficult decisions about public spending. Some residents believe money would be better spent on essential services such as road maintenance, libraries and community facilities.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a three-minute speech for a local council budget meeting arguing whether additional public money should be invested in winter festivals. Consider tourism, economic benefits, community wellbeing and competing financial priorities. Include a realistic proposal for how the council should allocate its resources.

77. Should Employers Introduce Shorter Working Hours During Winter?

Dark mornings, early sunsets and cold weather can make the winter working day feel particularly demanding. Some people argue that shorter winter working hours could improve wellbeing, allow employees to spend more time outdoors during daylight and reduce commuting in difficult conditions. Critics believe seasonal reductions in working hours would create financial difficulties and disrupt essential services.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a business opinion article arguing whether companies should introduce shorter working days during the winter months. Consider employee wellbeing, productivity, business costs and the challenges faced by industries that cannot easily reduce operating hours. Use persuasive reasoning to convince employers that your preferred approach would benefit their organisations.

78. Should Winter Sports Be Compulsory in Schools?

Skiing, ice skating, sledging and other winter sports can encourage physical activity and introduce students to unfamiliar experiences. However, specialist equipment, transport costs and safety concerns can make these activities difficult to organise. Some students may also feel uncomfortable participating in sports that require particular physical skills or involve a risk of injury.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a school sports podcast debating whether winter sports should become a compulsory part of physical education. Include a student presenter interviewing a PE teacher, a winter sports enthusiast and a student who opposes the proposal. Use contrasting viewpoints and persuasive questioning before delivering your own recommendation.

79. Should People Be Fined for Failing to Clear Snow from Pavements Outside Their Homes?

Heavy snowfall can make pavements slippery and dangerous, particularly for older people, wheelchair users and anyone with limited mobility. Some argue that homeowners should be legally responsible for clearing snow and ice from the pavements outside their properties. Others believe this would unfairly burden people who are physically unable to clear snow or cannot afford suitable equipment.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an open letter to your local council arguing whether residents should face fines for failing to clear snow from nearby pavements. Consider public safety, personal responsibility, accessibility and the difficulties faced by vulnerable residents. Propose a fair and practical approach to keeping pedestrian routes safe during winter.

80. Should Every Student Be Entitled to One Official Snow Day Each Winter?

Imagine a school policy allowing every student one guaranteed snow day during winter, regardless of whether enough snow actually falls. Supporters might argue that students deserve an opportunity to enjoy the season, take a break from academic pressure and experience the excitement traditionally associated with unexpected school closures. Critics could question whether an additional day off is justified when schools already provide scheduled holidays.

Persuasive writing challenge: Develop a persuasive campaign proposing the introduction of an annual National Snow Day for students. Create a memorable slogan, write a short campaign manifesto and prepare a 60-second promotional video script. Use humour, emotional appeals and logical arguments to convince school leaders that one extra winter holiday would be worth celebrating.

9. Funny & Unusual Christmas Persuasive Writing Topics

Should Santa Claus be forced to retire? Are elves being exploited in the North Pole? And should anyone who puts pineapple on Christmas pizza face a lifetime ban from festive celebrations? Not every persuasive argument needs to tackle a serious issue. Sometimes, the most entertaining debates begin with completely ridiculous questions.

These ten funny Christmas persuasive writing topics encourage students to experiment with humour, exaggeration, satire and imaginative arguments while developing genuine persuasive writing skills. From mock courtroom trials and political campaigns to television interviews, complaint letters and advertising pitches, each challenge asks students to defend an unusual position with convincing reasoning.

The questions might be absurd, but the writing skills are real. Students must still consider their audience, organise their arguments, anticipate objections and use persuasive techniques to make even the most outrageous proposal sound reasonable.

81. Should Santa Claus Be Forced to Retire?

Santa Claus has supposedly delivered presents around the world for centuries, working an exhausting Christmas Eve shift that involves visiting millions of homes in a single night. Some argue that his extraordinary experience makes him irreplaceable, while others believe that modern technology, changing working practices and the demands of the job mean it is finally time for someone younger to take over.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal retirement recommendation to the North Pole Employment Board arguing whether Santa should be required to retire. Consider his age, working conditions, professional experience and the potential consequences of replacing such a recognisable public figure. Include at least one counterargument and propose a suitable retirement or succession plan.

82. Should Christmas Elves Form a Trade Union?

Santa's elves are responsible for manufacturing toys, wrapping presents, maintaining equipment and preparing for the busiest night of the year. Yet very little is known about their wages, working hours, holiday entitlement or workplace conditions. Some believe that elves should organise collectively to demand better treatment, while others argue that their work is a magical vocation rather than an ordinary job.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a dramatic North Pole trade union meeting. Deliver a persuasive speech as the leader of the newly established International Federation of Christmas Elves, demanding improved working conditions. Include three specific demands, respond to objections from Santa's management team and finish with a powerful rallying cry.

83. Should Rudolph Be Paid More Than the Other Reindeer?

Rudolph's famous glowing nose has supposedly saved Christmas by allowing Santa's sleigh to travel through thick fog. But does this extraordinary contribution justify a higher salary, additional privileges or a leadership position? The other reindeer might argue that the sleigh cannot fly without their combined efforts and that rewarding one individual would undermine teamwork.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a televised debate between Rudolph, the other reindeer's union representative and Santa's chief financial officer. Argue whether Rudolph deserves performance-related pay or whether all reindeer should receive equal compensation. Explore fairness, individual achievement and the importance of teamwork through humorous but logically developed arguments.

84. Should the Grinch Be Banned from Christmas Celebrations?

The Grinch has a notorious history of attempting to steal Christmas, making him an unlikely candidate for the guest list at any festive gathering. However, his eventual change of heart suggests that even the most determined Christmas opponent can learn the value of generosity and community. Should his previous behaviour permanently exclude him from celebrations, or does everyone deserve a second chance?

Persuasive writing challenge: Write the closing argument for a mock courtroom trial titled The People vs the Grinch. Argue whether the Grinch should be banned from Christmas celebrations or welcomed back into the community. Use evidence from the familiar story, address the opposing case and persuade the jury to deliver your preferred verdict.

85. Should Christmas Decorations Be Allowed to Stay Up Until Easter?

Every January, households face the disappointing task of dismantling their Christmas decorations. Some people believe festive lights, colourful ornaments and decorated trees should remain on display for as long as they bring happiness. Others argue that leaving Christmas decorations up for months makes homes look untidy and removes the excitement of decorating again the following December.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a humorous lifestyle blog post titled Why Taking Down Christmas Decorations in January Is a Terrible Idea or The Case Against Year-Round Christmas Chaos. Use exaggerated examples, witty comparisons and persuasive reasoning to convince readers that your preferred decoration policy should become the new social norm.

86. Should Santa Replace His Reindeer with Delivery Drones?

Flying reindeer have served Santa faithfully for generations, but modern delivery companies increasingly rely on sophisticated technology to transport goods. Could a fleet of automated drones deliver Christmas presents more efficiently, or would replacing the reindeer destroy the magic of Christmas? There are also important questions about technical failures, navigation, security and the environmental consequences of manufacturing millions of drones.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a business pitch for a fictional technology company hoping to secure the North Pole's Christmas delivery contract. Argue whether Santa should modernise his operations with delivery drones or continue relying on his traditional reindeer team. Include a product slogan, three persuasive selling points and a response to concerns about reliability and Christmas magic.

87. Should Christmas Crackers Be Banned for Containing Terrible Jokes?

Christmas crackers promise festive excitement, but their contents frequently include flimsy paper crowns, tiny plastic toys and jokes so predictable that they produce more groans than laughter. Some people consider these disappointing surprises an essential part of Christmas dinner, while others believe crackers are wasteful, overpriced and desperately in need of improvement.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an entertaining complaint letter to the fictional National Association of Christmas Cracker Manufacturers. Demand either a complete ban on traditional Christmas crackers or a radical improvement in their contents. Use humour, rhetorical questions, exaggerated examples and a convincing proposal for what should replace the current system.

88. Should Snowmen Have Legal Rights?

Every winter, snowmen are constructed in gardens, parks and playgrounds, only to be abandoned when temperatures rise. Some lose their carrot noses, others are deliberately knocked over, and almost all eventually melt without anyone attempting to save them. If snowmen could speak, would they demand legal protection, better working conditions or the right to be relocated to colder climates?

Persuasive writing challenge: Deliver a passionate speech to a fictional United Nations conference as the president of the International Snowman Rights Association. Argue that snowmen deserve legal recognition and protection from deliberate destruction. Propose three specific rights, anticipate objections about their temporary existence and persuade delegates to support your campaign.

89. Should the Naughty List Be Abolished?

According to Christmas tradition, Santa keeps a record of children's behaviour throughout the year, rewarding those on the Nice List and potentially withholding presents from those on the Naughty List. But is it fair to judge an entire year of behaviour using a simple good-or-bad classification? Some argue that the Naughty List encourages kindness and responsibility, while others believe it creates anxiety and fails to recognise that everyone makes mistakes.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for a North Pole television news investigation titled The Naughty List Scandal. Include an investigative reporter, a representative from Santa's Behaviour Assessment Department and two children with opposing opinions. Use persuasive questioning and conflicting arguments to examine whether the Naughty List should be abolished, reformed or defended.

90. Should Christmas Become a Competitive Olympic Sport?

Christmas preparations require an impressive range of skills, including speed-wrapping presents, decorating trees, untangling fairy lights, assembling complicated toys and surviving crowded shopping centres. Some enthusiasts believe these activities deserve international recognition, while critics argue that turning Christmas into a competition would undermine the spirit of relaxation and togetherness.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a formal presentation to the fictional International Christmas Olympic Committee arguing whether Christmas activities should become competitive sporting events. Propose at least three events, explain how competitors would be judged and persuade the committee that your Christmas Olympics would attract global audiences. Address concerns about fairness, safety and whether competition belongs in festive celebrations.

10. Challenging Christmas Debate Topics for Older Students

Behind the festive decorations, cheerful advertisements and familiar traditions, Christmas raises complex questions about economics, inequality, religion, cultural identity and social responsibility. Should governments spend public money on Christmas celebrations? Does the pressure to create a perfect holiday damage people's wellbeing? And can a celebration associated with generosity ever be separated from consumerism?

These ten challenging Christmas persuasive writing topics are designed for older students who are ready to explore controversial issues, evaluate competing arguments and develop more sophisticated persuasive techniques. Unlike questions with straightforward answers, these debates require students to consider the consequences of different positions, distinguish between personal beliefs and public responsibilities, and acknowledge the limitations of their own arguments.

Through parliamentary speeches, investigative journalism, philosophical debates, policy proposals and persuasive essays, students can practise constructing nuanced arguments supported by evidence, ethical reasoning and carefully considered counterarguments.

91. Has Christmas Become a Celebration of Wealth Rather Than Generosity?

Christmas is frequently associated with kindness, generosity and spending time with loved ones. Yet advertising campaigns, luxury gift guides and social media displays of expensive celebrations can create the impression that a successful Christmas depends on how much money people spend. Families with limited financial resources may feel pressure to meet expectations that are increasingly difficult to afford.

Some argue that modern Christmas culture has transformed generosity into a competition based on material wealth. Others believe that exchanging gifts and spending money are simply expressions of affection, and that the meaning of Christmas depends on individual attitudes rather than commercial activity.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a thought-provoking newspaper editorial titled The Price of Christmas: Has Generosity Become a Luxury? Examine the relationship between wealth, social expectations and the meaning of generosity. Use examples of consumer culture, consider the experiences of different socioeconomic groups and challenge the assumption that expensive celebrations necessarily reflect greater happiness or affection.

92. Should Governments Use Public Money to Fund Christmas Celebrations?

Local authorities often contribute funding towards Christmas lights, festive markets, public decorations and community events. Supporters argue that these celebrations encourage tourism, support businesses and improve community wellbeing. However, critics question whether public money should be spent on seasonal entertainment when essential services may be facing financial difficulties.

The issue becomes particularly complicated in communities where residents have different religious beliefs, cultural traditions and priorities for public spending.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare a speech for a local government budget debate arguing whether public funding for Christmas celebrations should be increased, reduced or eliminated. Consider economic benefits, cultural inclusion, public accountability and the opportunity cost of spending money on festive events. Propose a realistic funding policy and respond to at least two opposing arguments.

93. Should Christmas Be a Secular Celebration Rather Than a Religious Holiday?

Christmas has Christian religious origins, but many people now celebrate it primarily through gift-giving, family gatherings, decorations and seasonal entertainment. Some believe that its transformation into a widely celebrated cultural event allows people from different backgrounds to participate. Others argue that separating Christmas from its religious significance risks erasing the beliefs and traditions that gave the holiday its original meaning.

Can Christmas successfully exist as both a religious observance and a secular cultural celebration, or do these interpretations inevitably conflict?

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a respectful television discussion between a Christian religious leader, a secular historian, a non-religious Christmas celebrant and a cultural commentator. Explore whether Christmas should be understood primarily as a religious or cultural occasion. Give each participant a carefully reasoned position, include thoughtful challenges and conclude with a persuasive argument about how different interpretations can coexist.

94. Does the Pressure to Have a Perfect Christmas Do More Harm Than Good?

Christmas films, advertisements and social media often portray the holiday as a flawless occasion filled with beautiful decorations, elaborate meals, expensive presents and harmonious family gatherings. These idealised images can create excitement and anticipation, but they may also encourage unrealistic expectations.

For people experiencing financial hardship, grief, loneliness or difficult family relationships, the contrast between festive ideals and personal circumstances can be particularly uncomfortable. However, others argue that aspirational Christmas imagery provides enjoyment, hope and an opportunity to escape everyday concerns.

Persuasive writing challenge: Create a script for an investigative podcast episode titled The Perfect Christmas Myth. Examine whether society's idealised portrayal of Christmas contributes to unnecessary emotional and financial pressure. Consider the influence of advertising, social media and family expectations, and develop a persuasive argument about whether festive culture needs to change.

95. Should Employers Be Legally Required to Accommodate Different Religious and Cultural Holidays?

In many countries, Christmas is recognised through public holidays and workplace closures, while employees celebrating other religious or cultural occasions may need to request annual leave. Some argue that employers should offer greater flexibility so workers can observe the holidays most meaningful to them. Others believe that coordinating individual holiday preferences would create significant practical challenges, particularly for smaller businesses and essential services.

The debate raises broader questions about equality, religious freedom, employment rights and the relationship between cultural traditions and national calendars.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a formal policy proposal recommending whether employers should introduce flexible religious and cultural holiday entitlements. Consider fairness, operational requirements, employee wellbeing and the challenges of implementing a consistent policy. Support your recommendation with clear reasoning and address potential objections from employers and employees.

96. Is Charitable Giving an Adequate Response to Poverty at Christmas?

Food banks, toy appeals, community fundraising events and charitable donations provide valuable assistance to people experiencing hardship during Christmas. However, some critics argue that seasonal charity campaigns address the immediate symptoms of poverty without tackling its underlying causes, including low incomes, housing costs and unequal access to opportunities.

Others believe that charitable organisations provide essential support that cannot wait for long-term political or economic reform.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write a persuasive essay responding to the statement: Christmas Charity Treats the Symptoms of Poverty Rather Than Its Causes.

Evaluate the responsibilities of individuals, charitable organisations, businesses and governments. Consider whether immediate assistance and structural reform should be viewed as competing priorities or complementary approaches. Develop a nuanced conclusion supported by ethical reasoning and relevant evidence.

97. Should Christmas Advertising Be Subject to Stricter Regulations?

Christmas advertising frequently uses emotional storytelling, nostalgic imagery, celebrity endorsements and carefully constructed messages about family, happiness and belonging. These techniques can create memorable campaigns and help businesses reach consumers. However, critics argue that festive advertisements sometimes exploit emotional vulnerability, encourage excessive spending or reinforce unrealistic expectations about family life.

The challenge is determining where legitimate persuasion ends and manipulation begins.

Persuasive writing challenge: Prepare the opening statement for a parliamentary committee hearing investigating Christmas advertising practices. Argue whether governments should introduce stricter regulations on emotionally manipulative festive marketing. Define the types of advertising you believe should be restricted, explain the potential consequences for consumers and businesses, and address concerns about commercial freedom.

98. Should Society Challenge the Expectation That Everyone Must Enjoy Christmas?

Christmas is often presented as a universally joyful occasion, with public celebrations, festive music, workplace parties and social expectations encouraging widespread participation. Yet not everyone celebrates Christmas, and some people associate the season with difficult memories, personal loss, financial stress or simply a lack of interest.

Supporters of festive traditions argue that shared celebrations strengthen communities and create positive social experiences. Others believe that expecting universal enthusiasm can marginalise people who experience the season differently.

Persuasive writing challenge: Write an opinion column for a national magazine titled The Right Not to Celebrate Christmas. Argue whether society should become more accepting of people who choose not to participate in festive traditions. Consider personal freedom, social inclusion, workplace expectations and the distinction between celebrating enthusiastically and expecting others to do the same.

99. Should Christmas Spending Be Discouraged During a Cost-of-Living Crisis?

When households face rising living costs and financial uncertainty, expensive Christmas celebrations can place additional pressure on family budgets. Some financial campaigners encourage people to reduce spending, avoid unnecessary debt and reconsider expectations surrounding presents and entertainment.

However, Christmas shopping also supports retailers, hospitality businesses, seasonal workers and local economies. A significant reduction in consumer spending could create difficulties for industries that depend heavily on festive sales.

Persuasive writing challenge: Script a current affairs television debate between an economist, a small business owner, a financial adviser and a consumer representative. Explore whether governments and public organisations should actively encourage people to reduce Christmas spending during periods of economic hardship. Include arguments about household finances, employment, economic growth and personal choice, followed by a persuasive closing statement supporting your preferred position.

100. Should Christmas Traditions Change to Reflect the Values of Modern Society?

Christmas celebrations have evolved considerably over time, incorporating religious observances, cultural customs, commercial practices and family traditions. Today, changing attitudes towards environmental sustainability, equality, consumerism, cultural diversity and personal wellbeing are encouraging people to reconsider how the holiday should be celebrated.

Some believe that traditions must evolve to remain meaningful and inclusive. Others argue that constantly adapting established customs risks weakening the sense of continuity, identity and belonging that makes Christmas special.

Persuasive writing challenge: Deliver the closing speech in a formal debate on the motion: This House Believes That Christmas Traditions Must Evolve to Reflect Modern Society.

Develop a sophisticated argument that draws on at least three issues explored throughout this collection, such as environmental responsibility, cultural inclusion, consumerism or social expectations. Acknowledge the strongest argument from the opposing team, explain why your position remains more convincing and finish with a memorable statement that challenges your audience to reconsider what Christmas should represent in the future.

Persuasive Writing Tips & Christmas Classroom Activities

A strong persuasive writing activity does more than ask students to choose a side. It encourages them to explain their reasoning, anticipate objections, select convincing evidence and adapt their language to a particular audience.

The 100 Christmas persuasive writing topics above can be used for much more than traditional essays. They work equally well as classroom debates, persuasive speeches, newspaper editorials, podcast scripts, advertising campaigns and collaborative writing challenges.

The following teaching strategies, persuasive writing techniques and practical classroom activities will help students transform their festive opinions into well-structured, convincing arguments.

How to Turn Christmas Persuasive Writing Topics into Classroom Debates

Classroom debates provide an engaging way to develop persuasive speaking, critical thinking and active listening skills. Christmas debate topics are particularly effective because students often have strong opinions about familiar traditions, making it easier to introduce the principles of argument and rebuttal.

A successful debate should require students to do more than repeat their personal preferences. They need to justify their positions, consider alternative perspectives and respond thoughtfully to opposing arguments.

1. Choose a debatable Christmas question

Select a topic that allows students to develop convincing arguments on both sides.

For example:

Should schools ban homework over the Christmas holidays?

This question works well because students can explore competing priorities, including academic progress, personal wellbeing, family responsibilities and the purpose of school holidays.

Avoid questions that have only one reasonable answer or depend entirely on personal taste.

2. Divide students into opposing teams

Assign one team to support the motion and another to oppose it.

For an additional challenge, ask students to defend the position they personally disagree with. This encourages them to consider alternative viewpoints rather than relying entirely on their existing opinions.

3. Give students time to prepare

Ask each team to develop:

• Three clear arguments supporting its position.

• Relevant examples, evidence or logical explanations.

• Two potential counterarguments.

• Responses to the opposing team's strongest claims.

• A memorable opening or closing statement.

Encourage students to distinguish between statements of opinion and arguments supported by reasoning.

4. Structure the debate

A simple classroom debate might follow this format:

Debate Stage	Suggested Time
Opening Argument — Team A	2 minutes
Opening Argument — Team B	2 minutes
Supporting Arguments	3 minutes per team
Rebuttals and Responses	2 minutes per team
Closing Statements	1 minute per team
Class Vote and Reflection	5 minutes

Adjust the timings according to students' ages, confidence and experience.

5. Finish with reflection

Rather than simply announcing a winner, ask students to evaluate which arguments were most convincing and why.

Did a speaker use particularly effective evidence? Was a counterargument successfully challenged? Did anyone change their opinion after listening to the debate?

This reflection helps students recognise that persuasive writing and speaking depend on the quality of an argument, not simply how strongly someone expresses an opinion.

Essential Persuasive Writing Techniques for Students

Whether students are writing a Christmas opinion article, delivering a speech or scripting a festive television debate, persuasive writing techniques help them communicate their arguments more effectively.

The strongest persuasive writing combines logical reasoning with language that engages the intended audience.

Rhetorical Questions

Rhetorical questions encourage readers or listeners to consider an argument without requiring a direct answer.

Should students really spend their Christmas holidays worrying about homework deadlines instead of enjoying a well-earned break?

This question encourages the audience to consider the fairness of Christmas homework while implying that the answer should be obvious.

Emotive Language

Emotive language appeals to the audience's feelings, values and experiences.

No child should spend Christmas morning feeling forgotten simply because their family cannot afford expensive presents.

Words such as forgotten and cannot afford encourage readers to consider the emotional consequences of financial inequality.

Emotive language can strengthen an argument, but it should not replace factual evidence or logical reasoning.

Facts, Statistics and Evidence

Relevant evidence helps establish credibility and demonstrates that an argument is based on more than personal preference.

For example, a student arguing against excessive Christmas packaging could investigate how different materials are recycled, compare packaging alternatives and reference reliable environmental research.

Students should use accurate, verifiable information rather than inventing statistics to make their arguments sound convincing.

Direct Address

Direct address uses words such as you and your to engage readers personally.

Imagine opening your Christmas presents and discovering that every gift has been wrapped in layers of unnecessary plastic.

This technique encourages readers to picture themselves in a particular situation and consider how they might respond.

Repetition

Repeating an important word or phrase can reinforce a central argument and make it more memorable.

We need a Christmas that values kindness. We need a Christmas that respects our planet. We need a Christmas that everyone can enjoy.

Repetition is particularly effective in persuasive speeches, campaigns and advertising.

The Rule of Three

Grouping three related ideas creates rhythm and emphasis.

Christmas should be affordable, inclusive and environmentally responsible.

Students can use this technique to organise their main arguments or create memorable concluding statements.

Counterarguments and Rebuttals

Strong persuasive writers acknowledge that reasonable people may disagree with their position.

For example:

Some argue that Christmas homework helps students maintain their academic progress. However, a short break from formal assignments may provide valuable opportunities for rest, family time and independent learning.

Acknowledging an opposing argument demonstrates thoughtful reasoning. Responding to it gives the writer an opportunity to strengthen their own position.

Ethos, Pathos and Logos

Older students can develop their arguments further by exploring three classical methods of persuasion:

• Ethos (credibility): Establishing trust through reliable evidence, expertise and responsible reasoning.

• Pathos (emotion): Appealing to the audience's feelings, values and personal experiences.

• Logos (logic): Using clear explanations, relevant evidence and logical connections to support a conclusion.

For example, a persuasive speech about reducing Christmas food waste might combine evidence from a reliable environmental organisation (ethos), a description of families experiencing food insecurity (pathos), and a practical explanation of how better planning reduces waste (logos).

Encourage students to consider how these approaches can work together rather than relying exclusively on one technique.

Persuasive Writing Sentence Starters for Christmas Topics

Students sometimes have strong opinions but struggle to translate their ideas into clear, organised paragraphs.

Persuasive writing sentence starters provide useful scaffolding, particularly for younger learners, reluctant writers and students developing confidence with argumentative writing.

The following examples can be adapted to almost any Christmas persuasive writing or debate topic.

Introducing an Argument

• It is time we reconsidered the way we...

• There are several compelling reasons why...

• Although many people believe that..., I strongly argue that...

• Should we really continue to accept...?

• The question of whether... deserves serious consideration.

Developing a Persuasive Point

• One of the strongest arguments in favour of... is...

• A significant consequence of this decision would be...

• This issue is particularly important because...

• Consider what might happen if...

• The benefits of this approach extend beyond...

Introducing Evidence and Examples

• Research from a reliable source suggests that...

• One example that illustrates this problem is...

• Evidence supporting this argument can be found in...

• This becomes particularly clear when we consider...

• A useful comparison can be made between...

Acknowledging Opposing Viewpoints

• Critics of this proposal may argue that...

• It is understandable that some people believe...

• Supporters of the opposing position often suggest...

• Although this argument has some merit...

• One possible objection to this proposal is...

Responding to Counterarguments

• However, this argument overlooks the fact that...

• While this concern is reasonable, it fails to consider...

• A more convincing interpretation would be...

• Nevertheless, the long-term benefits outweigh...

• This objection can be addressed by...

Writing a Persuasive Conclusion

• Ultimately, the evidence suggests that...

• If we genuinely want to improve..., we must...

• The time has come to reconsider...

• Rather than continuing to accept..., we should...

• The choice is clear: we can either... or...

Teaching tip: Ask students to select three sentence starters and use them in a short persuasive paragraph responding to one of the Christmas questions above. Once they have developed confidence, challenge them to rewrite the paragraph without relying on the scaffolding.

5 Christmas Persuasive Writing Activities for the Classroom

The following Christmas classroom activities provide opportunities to practise persuasive writing through collaborative discussion, creative formats and independent challenges.

Each activity can be adapted for different age groups and requires minimal preparation.

Activity 1: The Christmas Debate Tournament

Skills: Argument construction, rebuttal, public speaking and critical thinking.

Organise a series of short debates using the Christmas persuasive writing topics from this collection.

Divide students into teams and assign each group a festive motion, such as:

• This House Would Ban Christmas Homework.

• This House Believes Christmas Has Become Too Commercialised.

• This House Would Abolish the Naughty List.

• This House Would Replace Christmas Presents with Experiences.

Give teams a limited preparation period before delivering their opening arguments and rebuttals.

After each debate, invite the audience to vote for the team that presented the most convincing arguments, rather than the position they personally agree with.

Extension challenge: Introduce a surprise motion during the final round. Give students five minutes to prepare before defending a position they have not previously considered.

Activity 2: The North Pole Complaints Department

Skills: Formal persuasive writing, audience awareness, tone and problem-solving.

Tell students that the North Pole has established an official complaints department to investigate concerns about Christmas operations.

Each student must write a persuasive complaint letter addressing a fictional festive problem.

Possible complaints include:

• Santa's reindeer are working unreasonable hours.

• Christmas presents are being delivered to the wrong addresses.

• The Naughty List contains unfair or inaccurate information.

• Elves are not receiving sufficient holiday entitlement.

• Christmas crackers contain unacceptable jokes.

Students should explain the problem, describe its consequences and propose a realistic solution within the fictional setting.

Encourage them to maintain a formal, convincing tone despite the humorous subject matter.

Extension challenge: Exchange letters between students and ask them to write persuasive responses on behalf of the North Pole Complaints Department, defending its policies or negotiating a compromise.

Activity 3: Christmas Controversies — The Podcast Challenge

Skills: Persuasive scripting, rhetorical techniques, discussion and audience engagement.

Ask students to create a short podcast episode exploring a controversial Christmas question.

Working individually or in pairs, students should select a topic, decide on their intended audience and prepare a persuasive script.

A simple episode structure could include:

1. An attention-grabbing opening question.

2. A clear introduction to the controversy.

3. Two or three developed arguments.

4. A contrasting viewpoint or imagined listener objection.

5. A persuasive conclusion inviting the audience to reconsider its opinion.

Students could explore whether Christmas advertisements are manipulative, whether traditional Christmas dinners are overrated or whether schools should organise festive celebrations.

Recording equipment is optional. Students can perform their scripts live or submit them as written pieces.

Extension challenge: Include a fictional interview with a guest who disagrees with the host. Students must anticipate the guest's arguments and prepare convincing responses.

Activity 4: Sell Me a Better Christmas

Skills: Advertising techniques, persuasive language, creativity and audience awareness.

Challenge students to design a persuasive advertising campaign promoting a change to a familiar Christmas tradition.

They might attempt to convince consumers to:

• Choose reusable gift wrapping.

• Replace expensive presents with shared experiences.

• Purchase second-hand Christmas decorations.

• Support independent local businesses.

• Reduce festive food waste.

Students should identify their target audience and decide which persuasive techniques are most likely to influence its behaviour.

Their campaign should include a memorable slogan, a short advertising script and a persuasive written explanation of the benefits of their proposal.

Encourage students to consider how emotive language, rhetorical questions, repetition and the rule of three can strengthen their message.

Extension challenge: Ask students to identify an ethical weakness in their own advertising campaign. Are they exaggerating the benefits, creating unnecessary pressure or making claims they cannot support with evidence?

Activity 5: The Christmas Persuasion Challenge — Change My Mind!

Skills: Spontaneous argument, persuasive paragraphs, counterarguments and reflection.

Display a controversial Christmas statement on the board.

For example:

Christmas should be celebrated only once every five years.

Ask students to decide whether they agree or disagree, then write a short persuasive paragraph defending their position.

Give them five minutes to develop an argument using at least two persuasive techniques.

Next, pair students with someone who holds the opposing viewpoint. Each student has one minute to explain their argument before listening to their partner's response.

After the discussion, students must revise their original paragraph to include a counterargument and rebuttal.

Extension challenge: Invite students to explain whether their opinion changed during the activity. If it did, ask them to identify the specific argument that influenced their thinking. If it did not, they should explain why the opposing argument was unconvincing.

How to Assess Christmas Persuasive Writing

Whether students are writing a formal essay, delivering a speech or creating a fictional television debate, assessment should focus on the effectiveness of their persuasion rather than the particular opinion they choose to defend.

A student arguing that Christmas should be abolished can produce an equally successful piece of persuasive writing as someone defending traditional celebrations, provided their arguments are clear, developed and convincing.

Use the following criteria to evaluate students' work:

Assessment Focus	What to Look For
Clear Viewpoint	A recognisable position maintained throughout
Argument Development	Reasons explained rather than simply listed
Evidence and Examples	Relevant, accurate support for important claims
Persuasive Techniques	Language choices that strengthen the argument
Audience and Purpose	Appropriate tone, format and level of formality
Counterarguments	Opposing viewpoints acknowledged and addressed
Organisation	Logical progression and effective transitions
Conclusion	A convincing ending that reinforces the main argument

For younger students, concentrate on expressing a clear opinion and supporting it with relevant reasons. Older or more confident writers can be challenged to evaluate evidence, anticipate objections and develop more nuanced arguments.

Final classroom challenge: Ask students to return to one of the 100 Christmas persuasive writing topics and produce a polished final piece in a format of their choice. They might write an editorial, deliver a speech, script a podcast, create a campaign or prepare a formal debate.

The aim is not simply to win an argument, but to demonstrate how thoughtful reasoning, effective language and an understanding of the audience can make an opinion genuinely persuasive.

Go Deeper: More Christmas Writing Prompts & Classroom Activities

Looking for more ways to bring festive creativity into your English lessons? Whether you're planning a Christmas writing workshop, developing seasonal literacy activities or searching for engaging tasks for the final weeks of term, we have plenty of inspiration to explore.

The following resources offer opportunities to move beyond persuasive writing and experiment with storytelling, poetry, descriptive language and interactive classroom challenges.

Explore More Christmas Writing Prompts

70 Christmas Creative Writing Prompts

Move from persuasive arguments to imaginative storytelling with 70 festive creative writing prompts. Explore Christmas mysteries, magical adventures, unusual characters, atmospheric settings and illustrated picture prompts designed to help students develop original narratives.

Christmas Poetry Writing Prompts

Introduce students to festive poetry through prompts exploring winter landscapes, Christmas memories, seasonal traditions, loneliness, wonder and celebration. Includes opportunities to experiment with imagery, symbolism, figurative language and different poetic forms.

Christmas Ghost Story Ideas

Bring a little Victorian atmosphere into the classroom with Christmas ghost story prompts inspired by Dickensian traditions, mysterious visitors, haunted houses and supernatural winter encounters. Ideal for exploring suspense, atmosphere and the conventions of Gothic fiction.

Try Our Free Interactive Classroom Writing Tools

Creative Writing Challenge Wheel

Spin the wheel to discover one of 200 creative writing challenges across ten categories, including dialogue, description, figurative language, character development and writing constraints. Use it for quick lesson starters, writing workshops or end-of-term activities.

Roll a Story Generator

Combine randomly generated characters, settings, problems and plot twists to create unexpected story ideas across twelve genres. Students can roll individual elements, experiment with unusual combinations and develop their ideas into original narratives.

Build Your Own Roll a Story

Create a personalised storytelling game by choosing your own characters, settings, problems and additional writing categories. Teachers can design curriculum-linked activities, differentiated challenges and printable story grids, making this a flexible resource for individual, paired or group work.

Discover the Creative Writing Archive

For even more inspiration, explore the Creative Writing Archive, where you'll find hundreds of writing prompts, story ideas, descriptive writing exercises, poetry challenges and genre-based resources.

From festive storytelling to year-round creative writing activities, the archive offers a growing collection of resources for students, teachers and imaginative writers.

Final Thoughts: Making Christmas Persuasive Writing Meaningful and Memorable

Christmas provides a wonderful opportunity to make persuasive writing feel relevant, engaging and genuinely enjoyable. From light-hearted arguments about Santa's retirement and the rights of Christmas elves to more challenging discussions about consumerism, sustainability and social responsibility, festive debates encourage students to question familiar traditions and explore the reasoning behind their opinions.

These 100 Christmas persuasive writing topics and debate ideas have been designed to offer something for every classroom. Younger students can build confidence by defending their opinions on familiar Christmas traditions, while older students can explore complex ethical questions, evaluate competing perspectives and construct sophisticated arguments supported by evidence.

And persuasive writing doesn't have to mean another formal essay. A mock courtroom trial, a passionate parliamentary speech, an investigative podcast or an outrageous advertising campaign can provide just as many opportunities to practise rhetorical questions, emotive language, counterarguments and effective conclusions.

The most important lesson is that persuasion is about more than having a strong opinion. Students must learn to explain why their argument matters, understand the perspectives of others and choose language that genuinely influences their audience.

Whether you're planning a single festive lesson, organising a Christmas debate tournament or developing a longer persuasive writing unit, I hope these ideas help you create activities that challenge your students, encourage lively discussion and make those final weeks of term a little more memorable.

Now, choose a Christmas controversy, take a side and see just how convincing an argument your students can make.

Choose Your Next Adventure